Print View  
Lesson 8: Assessing the Validity of Commonly Held Assumptions

In times of shrinking expectations,...everyone feels like a victim and pushes away outsiders to defend his own corner.

~ Oscar Handlin

Goal: To gather data from a variety of sources to support or refute commonly held assumptions on immigrants and immigration policies

Objectives:

  • Students will suggest reasons for bias and stereotypes about immigrants
  • Students will reflect on discrepancies between facts and beliefs
  • Students will discuss the importance of and ways to achieve a voting public that is well informed and thinks critically about complex issues

Materials:

  • Video: “The Energy of a Nation”
  • Other relevant materials from local media, personal stories, and/or Appendix

Time Frame: Four to five class periods

Age Level: Middle school to adult

Vocabulary: Naturalization, Nativism

Relevant Subject Areas and Connection to Minnesota State High School Standards:

  • Inquiry and Research: History through Culture
  • Social Studies: Themes of United States History, Diverse Perspectives, Community Interaction, Institutions and Traditions in Society
Cycles of Nativism in U.S. History

Going Further

Minnesota Muslims Denounce Attacks, Brace for Harassment

Making the Connections

Commonly Held Assumptions: Data Collection

Jewish-American Experience Timeline

"The Energy of a Nation: Immigrants in America" video

Becoming Informed

Transforming Assumptions